Care Team
The research team conducted key informant interviews across disciplines, engaging physicians, nurse practitioners, and physician assistants. In most cases, there was little difference in the perspectives between these professionals. The concerns they expressed about the status of the primary care delivery system or the challenges they face as providers regardless of discipline. However, there were some key issues raised and differences in perspectives that will be important to explore as Rhode Island tries to heal its primary care system.
An overarching theme in these discussions is that the payment system and institutions create confusion on the role of physicians and nurse practitioners in primary care settings. For example, several providers across disciplines expressed that physicians and nurse practitioners are expected to practice independently, seeing the same complexity of patients, for the same length of visit, with the same access to clinical support personnel, despite obvious variances in length and type of training. Providers across disciplines expressed concerns about perceived changes in nurse practitioner training programs, specifically the perception that more training is being conducted virtually with less hands-on requirements. Notably, multiple providers across both disciplines felt the impacts of the difference in training between the two disciplines is lessened after about 10 years of practicing primary care.
Providers expressed the following sentiments:
“In the hospital, everyone’s role and scope are clear, but that’s not the case in primary care.”
A nurse practitioner said:
“I told (the medical director) that I thought a patient required an “MD level of care” but was told “that doesn’t exist at (name of institution redacted).” But when I went to negotiate my contract and wanted to be paid what a physician is paid, I was told that ‘isn’t done.’ If I am doing the same job, why am I not paid the same.”
Physicians also spoke about compensation from a different perspective:
“I value my NP and PA colleagues, but the closeness in our salaries isn’t fair. We train longer so we have less years to earn, and our debts are higher. I believe our expertise should be valued with higher compensation than our colleagues from other disciplines.”
Providers across disciplines expressed seeing the value of a diverse primary care workforce. The bulk of the providers also agreed that care teams should be physician-led and/or that some primary care patients are best cared for by a physician or with a physician-led team.
“As a pediatrician, I am lucky to have NPs on my team. But I believe care should be collaborative and physician led.”
A nurse practitioner said:
“More than once I have transferred a (primary care) patient to a doctor when they were super complex, especially early in my career. I would not stay at (name redacted) if they stopped letting me do that. That is happening some places.”
Providers also generally agreed that increased opportunity for collaboration would benefit providers and patients. However, providers shared that in most settings there is little to no opportunity for this collaboration due to structural barriers. Beyond structural challenges, several providers acknowledged cultural barriers as well.
From a physician:
“It isn’t surprising some (PAs and NPs) are uncomfortable seeking consultation. Many of us physicians aren’t well known for our humility. It is hard to teach humility to an adult.”
“In some places in the country, primary care providers are being replaced by (NPs). A colleague I went to residency with was laid off and replaced by an NP. In the health centers, providers are reimbursed the same, regardless of training. So, yeah, we think about this.”
On the topic of collaboration from nurse practitioners:
“I am afraid to (seek consultation from a physician) because they already think I shouldn’t be practicing (independently).”
“I think doctors are afraid of being replaced…. afraid they are losing value. So why would they want to help me?”
From a physician no longer practicing in a traditional primary care setting or a setting that includes nurse practitioners:
“When I was at (location with NPs), it felt very vulnerable to have this conversation. Nurse practitioners were my cherished colleagues and nothing good came of trying to discuss these issues, because the system was just going to treat (NPs and physicians) the same.”
| Title |
Organization/ Author(s) Names/Date |
Description and/or summary: Note, for the sake of brevity, some of the information below has been paraphrased. Please see source document for exact language. |
| To tackle the doctor shortage, RI must build programs for physician associates – Opinion |
The Providence Journal Dr. Kenneth Botelho June 28, 2025 |
Op-ed by Dr. Botelho discussing prioritizing physician associates as instrumental to address the primary care crisis in Rhode Island. The letter recommends investing in primary care fellowships and other innovations. |
| Suspected Medicaid fraud in RI sparks criminal probe, proposed changes |
WPRI Providence Eli Sherman June 2, 2025 |
News report on alleged fraud in the community health worker workforce and newly proposed regulations to address concerns. New regulations would remove standing orders, which would impact primary care providers. |
| Community Health Workers – Making a Difference in the Northern RI Community |
Care Transformation Collaborative – RI April 24, 2025 |
Organization report on community health workers including impact on primary care crisis |
| Nurse practitioners fill gap in primary care |
Providence Business News February 28, 2025 |
Media report highlighting a bill that failed in 2024 which would have provided grants to primary care sites that provide training for primary care providers, including NPs. |
| Primary Duties: Nurse practitioners playing bigger doctors disappear |
Providence Business News Katie Castellani February 28, 2025 |
Media report that highlights increase in NPs in RI and nationwide and features Brown Medical Group which has added 16 NPs recently. Discusses NP training requirements and team-based approaches to care. Highlights AMA’s concern about NP scope. |
| Are nurse practitioners taking too much responsibility in Rhode Island’s health care system? |
Providence Business News February 28, 2025 |
Media report that highlights 34% increase in NPs in RI in last five years. Includes a statement that AMA has raised concerns about NP’s role in care delivery. Includes a poll. |
| Finding a Primary Care Doctor Is Tough |
Boston Globe Jonathan Saltzman and Scooty Nickerson November 20, 2024 |
Media report on increases in NPs in primary care in MA and recent legislation there expanding the scope of practice for NPs to be able to practice unsupervised by a physician after 2 years. |
| Are nurse practitioners replacing doctors? They’re definitely reshaping health care. |
The Boston Globe Kara Miller October 21, 2024 |
Media report on role of NPs in primary care regionally. |
